I don’t know how to word this but I feel like a lot of complaints about the way schools treat children tend to… overlook. A lot of things.
Like I see a lot of posts about being careful how you talk to kids, how saying “I don’t care who started it” encourages abuse, how it’s wrong to make kids ask to use the bathroom or ask to get food. And I’m not saying these are inherently wrong, but I also never see anybody on those posts offer… alternative solutions to any of these critiques?
Let me break this down for y’all: I’m a TA at my first “official” year at this school. It’s severely underfunded. A lot of the kids are raised in poverty and surrounded by drug usage and gang violence. A lot of them have trauma they’re not equipped to deal with - which has, for some reason or another, gone undiagnosed or untreated. Maybe the parents don’t care, maybe caseworkers cases are too full, maybe the system is behind on paperwork. But they’re not getting treatment. You are in a room with approximately 20 of these kids, if not more. Over half the staff has either been moved, retired, quit, etc. Most of the staff are new, some even fresh out of college. We have no security cameras. We have one security guard. Many of these students come from broken homes - teachers and staff have been physically assaulted by unstable parents (and unstable students, if I’m being honest). Gunshots go off outside the school, this is a regular occurrence. Most of the new staff will quit before the year is over.
Teachers are not required to be experts in child psychology. They absolutely should be, but they’re not. They take.. maybe a few child psych courses.
As a teacher, it is your job to create structure for kids. You have to create a semblance of order.
I don’t wanna be the person to assume the worst in somebody, I would never do that. But we have a real issue of girls in the 4th and 5th grade levels skipping class to go to the bathroom or go to the nurse, when they’re actually just meeting up with boys in the hall. We’ve had kids leave classes and just walk out of the schools and into the city. We’ve had kids start fights who both claim the other student started it, and we have no way to tell who’s lying.
I’m not saying it’s not wrong to control a child’s bathroom schedule, or to dismiss their feelings - it ABSOLUTELY is. But the criticisms I always see for this are lobbied at.. the teachers. And not the institutions that push them to that point. Your school is in a dangerous neighborhood and you have 20+ kids to protect and watch over, you can’t have them walking out of the class to use the bathroom whenever they want - especially when some of them are flight risks. You can’t drop everything to help two students talk out a problem in-depth.
The district I am in is trying this new thing called “restorative circles” - where, whenever a student acts out or makes a scene or gets into a fight, you stop the class and you all talk about it as a group. It’s not a bad idea. The problem is, teachers also have a certain quota they have to meet. They have to teach for a certain amount of time, they have to fit in lesson plans and they only have so long to do it - because they have to fit them in in time for tests. The education system LOVES tests. It feeds off them. It uses them to measure how good of a job a teacher is doing, even when that’s a horrible form of measurement because not every kid tests well and all kids learn differently. They don’t have time to stop the entire class to talk out problems with the students, as wonderful of an idea as it is. And the system will not bend on this, it will not sacrifice one for the other. You have to find a way to make both work.
I’m not saying there aren’t bad teachers - oh my god there are. I STILL think the whole “no eating in class” thing is ridiculously stupid and controlling and I will take this to my grave. It is well known that abusers flock to jobs that give them positions of power over vulnerable people - and teachers are not exempt from this critique. But the problem, the whole problem, is not teachers - it’s a system that doesn’t care about people. Not just students, but people. A few days ago I went to a professional development training all about how to help disabled students that was run by our districts “autism specialists”, that refused to compensate for me, a disabled adult, multiple times. It is an unspoken fact among many teachers in our district that the district does not care about our mental health and well being.
You want school to be better for kids?
Make it mandatory that teachers have a minor in child psychology. Fund schools. Pay teachers better. Lower class sizes. Provide free lunches for students and vending machines with snacks in them, provide free GOOD lunches for students cause I have seen school lunches and a lot of them suck ass. Stop making teachers pay out of pocket for their own supplies. Advocate for every classroom to have its own bathroom.
Every school I have ever been to has been a poorly maintained wreck that’s falling apart at the seams. And it’s not because the people working there don’t care - it’s because they care so much, for a cause that they will receive no funding for and no compensation for, that they’re just too burnt out to do anything anymore.










